Who knocked Toby out in the woods?
Sarah Scott
Updated on June 03, 2026
It was Jenna, confirmed (non-explicitly) in 401 when Jenna says to Emily “tell Toby I never meant to hurt him”. Toby only got hurt once that night so that must be what she was referring to. She did it to protect him, because again quoting Jenna, “it seems anyone who saw Alison that night is waking up dead”.